© 2026. The Trustees of Indiana University
Copyright Complaints
1229 East Seventh Street, Bloomington, Indiana 47405
News, Arts and Culture from WFIU Public Radio and WTIU Public Television
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

A Place for Film - Film Criticism

Episode 37 - Discussing Film Criticism

On this week's episode we invite Craig Simpson from the Lilly Library back to the show to discuss the current state of film criticism. We discuss our favorite film critics, how we read criticism, and how we go about critiquing films for the show.

In our opening segment, Andy and Jason discuss their experience seeing X-Men First Class. One of us loved it, the other had some problems. Listen in to see who's who! And Andy didn't have as much time to watch movies this week, but he did play a very cinematic video game with a Noir feel.  Jason also updates us on his quest to watch 300 movies in 12 months. Come back every week to see how he's doing.

And since this is Craig's second time on the podcast, it's up to him to list his 5 Favorite Films. He brings in a really interesting list.

After discussing film criticism at length, we take some time to play the Recommendations game. For the uninitiated, this game is when we list a category, and everyone tries to recommend a movie in that category. Feel free to comment on this post with your own categories, or send us a message on Twitter: @iucinemapodcast

External Links

  • Listen to past episodes
  • Subscribe to the podcast on iTunes
  • Films discussed in this episode:

    A Hard Days Night

    All That Jazz

    American Psycho

    Bourne Ultimatum

    Brazil

    Carlos

    Casablanca

    Cast Away

    Che

    Field of Dreams

    Fistful of Dollars

    For a Few Dollars More

    Ghost Writer

    Gosford Park

    Green Lantern

    Hard Boiled

    Hereafter

    Incendies

    LA Noire (game)

    M

    McCabe and Mrs. Miller

    Meek's Cutoff

    Mesrine

    Mission: Impossible 2

    Mr. Poppers Penguins

    Munich

    Once upon a time in America

    Once Upon A Time in the West

    One False Move

    Picnic at Hanging Rock

    Queen of the Sun

    Rear Window

    Red Cliff

    Silent Light

    Sweet smell of success

    The American

    The Good, The Bad, And the Ugly

    The Graduate

    The Kennel Murder Case

    The Stranger

    Third Man

    Titanic

    Twilight

    West Side Story

    X-men

    X-men First Class

    A Hard Days Night

    All That Jazz

    American Psycho

    Bourne Ultimatum

    Brazil

    Carlos

    Casablanca

    Cast Away

    Che

    Field of Dreams

    Fistful of dollars

    For a few dollars more

    Ghost writer

    Gosford Park

    Green Lantern

    Hard Boiled

    Hereafter

    Incendies

    LA Noire (game)

    M

    McCabe and Mrs. Miller

    Meek's Cutoff

    Mesrine

    Mission: Impossible 2

    Mr. Poppers Penguins

    Munich

    Once upon a time in America

    Once Upon A Time in the West

    One False Move

    Picnic at Hanging Rock

    Queen of the Sun

    Rear Window

    Red Cliff

    Silent Light

    Sweet smell of success

    The American

    The Good, The Bad, And the Ugly

    The Graduate

    The Kennel Murder Case

    The Stranger

    Third Man

    Titanic

    Twilight

    West Side Story

    Xmen

    Xmen first class

    External Links

    • Listen to past episodes
    • Subscribe to the podcast on iTunes