© 2026. The Trustees of Indiana University
Copyright Complaints
1229 East Seventh Street, Bloomington, Indiana 47405
News, Arts and Culture from WFIU Public Radio and WTIU Public Television
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Shalooby’s hoax becomes an internet phenomenon

Jeff LaFave (BTown Moose) photoshopped "Shalooby's" onto a picture of Cafe Pizzaria, which closed in August.
Jeff LaFave (BTown Moose) photoshopped "Shalooby's" onto a picture of Cafe Pizzaria, which closed in August.

Local restaurant Shalooby’s attracts Indiana football fans from across the country to enjoy a post-game meal.

But this “beloved” eatery does not exist. It’s an internet hoax.

IU adjunct Jeff LaFave is the person behind the joke. He saw Shalooby’s in an article filled with AI-generated images and false Bloomington factoids. Soon, he posted on his X account, BTown Moose.

what in the hell is "Shalooby's," AI article?? pic.twitter.com/pIMS320mmC — moose (@btownmoose) October 17, 2024

“I started daydreaming about it, made a photoshop of it in the old Cafe Pizzaria building,” LaFave said. “Just for a one-off joke I didn’t think would go very far.”

Related:  Cafe Pizzaria, Bloomington’s oldest pizza restaurant, closes

But far did it go. LaFave’s creation went viral in a matter of hours. Fellow X users reposted the photoshopped image and dubbed it as the best place to get a soggy sandwich.

IU fans wrote “Shalooby’s” across the windshields of their cars. They also wrote it on signs that could be seen on Fox’s Big Noon Kickoff show, which attracted a huge crowd outside Memorial Stadium last week before the IU-Nebraska game.

Shalooby’s even has its own website that LaFave had no part in making.

“It just kind of made me feel like I was trapped in a Twilight Zone episode,” LaFave said. “I told a joke so good everyone else wanted to tell it, and it was out of my hands.”

LaFave enjoys watching the joke take a life of its own and hopes that maybe it will one day become a reality.

Read more:  IU football’s ‘multi-generational’ season rolls on with 31-17 victory

Claire is a journalism student and Ernie Pyle Scholar at the Indiana University Media School. She has interned with the International Business Times UK in London and the Marblehead Current in Massachusetts. She also works for the Arnolt Center for Investigative Journalism.