An Indiana University professor is under investigation for an alleged violation of Indiana’s “intellectual diversity” law.
Ben Robinson, professor of Germanic Studies, said it involves SEA 202, which law requires instructors to foster “free inquiry, free expression and intellectual diversity” in the classroom. The law also sets up a complaint process, so faculty can be reported for alleged violations.
Read more: Indiana college 'intellectual diversity' and tenure law into effect
Robinson said an anonymous person filed a complaint on IU’s Bias Incident Reporting web page, which is separate from how IU tracks alleged SEA 202 violations. That system is called EthicsPoint. The distinction is important. IU’s Bias Response Team doesn’t “take disciplinary action, conduct formal investigations, or impinge on free speech rights and academic freedom,” according to the university.
Robinson said someone in the administration intervened and elevated the complaint as an SEA 202 violation, which has serious implications. A professor’s tenure can be in jeopardy.
Read more: ACLU sues IU and Purdue to stop intellectual diversity law
IU spokespeople didn’t immediately respond to requests for comment. The College of Arts and Sciences’ 2024 policy states an investigation will determine if the complaint has standing and sufficient evidence.
Robinson said he discussed being jailed for civil disobedience while protesting at an Israeli Consulate. He said it was a lesson on the master-slave dialectic, the prisoner’s dilemma and what it’s like being in prison. Robinson has been involved in activism and support for Palestine, among several other causes on campus.
Robinson said he is “extremely disappointed and extremely indignant.”
“I don’t believe the case has standing,” he said.
Robinson is concerned about the precedent his case could set, meaning someone within the university could see any complaint and refile it as an SEA 202 violation.
“If my case has standing, we can just take any random anonymous complaint and redirect it as an SEA 202 complaint," Robinson said. “And have a professor investigated for making us uncomfortable.”
Aubrey is our higher education reporter and a Report For America corps member. Contact her at aubmwrig@iu.edu or follow her on X @aubreymwright.
